For leaders before this see: List of Presidents of the British Virgin Islands
- Edward John Cameron (1887-1894)
- Alexander R. Mackay (1894-1896)
- Nathaniel George Cookman (1896-1903)
- Robert Stephen Earl (1903-1910)
- Thomas Leslie Hardtman Jarvis (1910-1919)
- Herbert Walter Peebles (1919-1922)
- R. Hargrove (1922-1923)
- Otho Lewis Hancock (1923-1926)
- Frank Cecil Clarkson (1926-1934)
- Donald Percy Wailling (1934-1946)
- John Augustus Cockburn Cruikshank (1946-1954)
- Henry Anthony Camilio Howard (1954-1956)
- Geoffrey Pole Allesbrook (1956-1959)
- Gerald Jackson Bryan (1959-1962)
- Martin Samuel Staveley (1962-1967)
- John Sutherland Thomson (1967-1971)
