- John Pickering (1741)
- John Hunt (1741-1750)
- James Purcell (1750-1751)
- John Purcell (1751-1775)
- John Nugent (1775-1782)
- Richard Hetherington (1811-18??)
- Edward Hay Drummond Hay (1839-1850)
- John Cornell Chads (1852-1854)
- Cornelius Hendricksen Kortright (1854-1857)
- Thomas Price (1859-1861)
- James Robert Longden (1861-1864)
- Sir Arthur Carlos Henry Rumbold (1866-1869)
- Alexander Wilson Muir (1869-1872)
- Richard Mahoney Hickson (1873-1879)
- John Kemys Spencer Churchill (1879-1882)
- Richard Henry Kortright Dyett (1882-1884)
- Fredrick Augustus Pickering (1884-1887)
